PCV Valve ticking after oil change

Forums

General Forum

Performance

V8 Dakotas

Forum Tools

19:58:22 - 04/19/2024

V6 Dakotas

From

Message

Pete
Dodge Dakota
JOIN HERE

1/24/2005
15:09:53

Subject: PCV Valve ticking after oil change
IP: Logged

Message:
I just bought a 97 Dakota about 2 months ago. 3.9L CC. I changed out the PCV Valve about 2 weeks ago, and just changed out the oil to AMSOIL this past weekend. After I put the Amsoil in I noticed the PCV valve was ticking like crazy, as it idles and revs up, but not as the revs come back down. Any ideas on why? I think I got the PCV valve at O'Reily's or AutoZone. I didn't notice it ticking before I changed the oil, and the oil change was overdue by about 1200 miles. I noticed that it still ticks when the intake hose is connected and the valve is out of the valve cover. Let me know what you think. Thanks.

stevebdak
Dodge Dakota
JOIN HERE

1/24/2005
15:38:13

RE: PCV Valve ticking after oil change
IP: Logged

Message:
The PCV valve is supose to make noise. If if was not making any noise, it needed replacing.

Pete
Dodge Dakota
JOIN HERE

1/24/2005
15:43:04

RE: PCV Valve ticking after oil change
IP: Logged

Message:
I haven't ever noticed this with any of the other 15 vehicles I've driven beofre, and I've changed the PCV Valve on all of them. I can hear it when I'm in the cab and the hood is shut. So is it supposed to be that loud? Thanks again.

Bob Lincoln
Dodge Dakota
JOIN HERE

1/24/2005
18:46:23

RE: PCV Valve ticking after oil change
IP: Logged

Message:
I've never heard a PCV valve 'tick'. I think it's a valve lifter.

garwood
Dodge Dakota
JOIN HERE

1/24/2005
20:29:11

RE: PCV Valve ticking after oil change
IP: Logged

Message:
Sure you got ALL the old valve out? I just mention this because I removed the vent tube on the opposite side on my 01. It looked a little funny, like not factory. When I stuck my finger in the hole to check for sludge I felt something. It took about ten minutes to get out, had to attach a shop vac to a small rubber hose to get it. Found a big plastic ring from the factory right angle hose fitting that had broken off. Maybe you got something like that bouncing around.

93dak4x4
Dodge Dakota
JOIN HERE

1/24/2005
23:11:48

RE: PCV Valve ticking after oil change
IP: Logged

Message:
the pcv valve doesnt have anything large enough that you would be able to hear from inside the cab of the truck. the ticking you have could be a lifter, fuel injector, or even a small exhaust or head gasket leak.

Pete
Dodge Dakota
JOIN HERE

1/25/2005
10:11:25

RE: PCV Valve ticking after oil change
IP: Logged

Message:
I actually held the PCV valve in my hand, while still connected to the intake hose, while the ngine was running, and felt and heard that it was ticking. I could also tell that the little ball inside the valve was rapidly moving up and down causing the ticking. I think I'll try and go get a new PCV valve from the dealer, and hopefully that will help. Thanks for the suggestions guys.

stevebdak
Dodge Dakota
JOIN HERE

1/25/2005
14:38:21

RE: PCV Valve ticking after oil change
IP: Logged

Message:
So just put your borken one back in. You know the one that is all clogged up and doesn't make any noise.

spt
Dodge Dakota
JOIN HERE

1/25/2005
14:41:33

RE: PCV Valve ticking after oil change
IP: Logged

Message:
Had that happen to me, turned out the new valve was faulty. Put a new one in to fix it.

zzark
Dodge Dakota
JOIN HERE

1/25/2005
17:33:12

RE: PCV Valve ticking after oil change
IP: Logged

Message:
I also have the 3.9 engine. I found that if I use the recommend PCV, it ticks/rattles constantly.
I now use the PCV that is listed for the V8 engine. It works, and without the noise.
BTW, you can't tell any physical difference in the 2 PCVs.

Pete
Dodge Dakota
JOIN HERE

1/26/2005
08:38:18

RE: PCV Valve ticking after oil change
IP: Logged

Message:
Thanks guys. I'll try buying another one for the V6 and get the one for the V8 just in case.

terraDAKtyl
GenIII

1/26/2005
17:53:56

RE: PCV Valve ticking after oil change
IP: Logged

Message:
I had the same problem once on my '98 3.9 It was very loud when first changed but guieted down significantly after a short time. SteveBdak is correct.